Showing posts with label Church. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Church. Show all posts

Thursday, November 29, 2007

Practical Criticism

Recently and quite accidentally, I came across a poem written by a contemporary Singapore poet which threw my mind back some 15 years to another poem I was reading then. I had studied the older poem in a strangely intent manner (for various reasons at that time), which was probably why it remained vivid in my mind all these years. The two poems are "churchgoing" and "Love III" respectively, I reproduce them in full here (with legal permission and the usual random clipart):

churchgoing

"and now we see through a glass darkly...." 1 cor 13:10

this morning i reached as far as
the clear glass doors of the sanctuary

and the affably opaque smile of the usher
on the other side, and peering in i saw

that someone had already taken
my favorite seat at the far anonymous

corner - a good seat by all accounts
because one only needs to shake no more

than three other hands when it came to
that part of the service, which had already

started - and i didn't want to interrupt God
who was evidently doing a great job with

the congregation, judging by their steadfast
glassy-eyed unanimity, from my clear glass

perspective anyway, so i turned around and
walked out the main gate, and lit my cigarette,

thinking of the parable of the virgins who
arrived too late and were locked out

(opaquely steadfastly oaken doors no doubt)
of the dinner banquet. then i sat down

for breakfast after that
and said my grace

but it wasn't quite the same at all.

- by Benzie Dio


Love III

Love bade me welcome, yet my soul drew back,
Guilty of dust and sin.
But quick-ey'd Love, observing me grow slack
From my first entrance in,
Drew nearer to me, sweetly questioning
If I lack'd anything.

"A guest," I answer'd, "worthy to be here";
Love said, "You shall be he."
"I, the unkind, the ungrateful?
ah my dear,I cannot look on thee."

Love took my hand and smiling did reply,
"Who made the eyes but I?"
"Truth, Lord, but I have marr'd them;
let my shame
Go where it doth deserve."

"And know you not," says Love,
"who bore the blame?"
"My dear, then I will serve."
"You must sit down," says Love,
"and taste my meat.
"So I did sit and eat.

- from "The Temple", George Herbert (1633)

"churchgoing" caught my attention for the reason that it refreshed some of the sentiments that I felt when I first read "Love III". Also, with the poem's modern and startlingly familiar (albeit intensely private) setting, it put me into a thinking mode about a number of issues that I have been mulling over regarding church life in the last few years - i.e. community, acceptance, and the "funny-shaped sheep" of Christ generally. I had written about these things in past blog entries, but I thought it would be interesting to look at them from a "literary" perspective.

So, purely for the fun of it, for old time's sake (and since one of the poets actually encouraged it), I am going to attempt a little comparative prac crit on the two poems. I am writing on the Blackberry on an airplane, so thoughts shall appear in bullets.

* Each poem is a re-working of a very well-known Bible verse. 1 Cor 13:10 in the case of "churchgoing" and Luke 12:37 for "Love III". In Herbert's work, the personification of God (Christ) is daringly human, tender, cajoling, solicitous even. Careful comparison with the scripture source shows how Herbert has juggled the characters and staging of the scene in his wonderfully witty way, worthy of a true Metaphysical poet. "churchgoing" likewise turns the preamble on its head in an intriguing way - we are used to the idea of the church looking into glass (perhaps darkly at first, if one was a dispensationalist) at the Truth, here someone outside the church looks in through clear glass instead, keenly observing what's going on inside. Who has the truer perspective? - is the question provoked throughout.


* In both poems, distance and space are used to convey the idea of intimacy, or the lack thereof, between deity and follower. At the start of both poems, the protaganist's desire to "draw near" to God is unspoken but palpable. In Love III, God and sinner becomes progressively closer, indeed the image of the eucharist brings about ultimate convergence- God is ingested by the sinner. In churchgoing, the opposite takes place, with the soul drawing back, guilty presumably of [cigarette?] dust and sin. God remains distant and untouched.


* I like the poignant social comedy in both. Who of us have not crashed a party of strangers and felt stupidly awkward at it? And who does not dread Friendship Break at service?!

* Cigarettes & dust. I am constantly amazed at the indictment ability of this. I am not a smoker, but I have a few close (Christian) friends who do (or did). The guilt surrounding the addiction is so real and so powerful, accentuated no doubt by the social stigma present in the community. One friend confided that she learnt to devise intricate strategies to make sure she gets a smoke when hanging out in a church setting without detection. Often it means having to find some place discreet in the middle of a gathering. She would have appreciated the "main gate" detail in "churchgoing".


* Finally, on Communion - it is still that undisputed image for fellowship with God and others. In "Love III", the sinner does sit and eat, which we may take as evidence of redemption. What about in "churchgoing"? In fact, the almost-churchgoer does sit and eat too, after voluntarily saying grace - should that not be taken as communion as well? But it is "not quite the same", he says. Why is that so? Did he feel that he dishonored God by turning up late at church ? (reminds me of the big signboard at my old church containing exactly that message for the latecomers every Sunday) Was it not the same because he would have preferred to eat (fellowship) with the glassy-eyed members of the congregation, and not alone? I am not sure one could tell entirely from this poem. Maybe it had something to do with practical self-criticism.

Thursday, August 16, 2007

No Mere Mortals

A rather heavy heart tonight, do want to pray but find it difficult to start. It's worse because one knows exactly why. An email, a phone call this afternoon made me realized how little I can really care about the golden commandment. Back home after DG, I flipped almost involuntarily to this passage in C.S Lewis' classic essay which I have read so many times in the past, but which strikes the conscience sharply every time:

"It is a serious thing to live in a society of possible gods and goddesses, to remember that the dullest and most uninteresting person you talk to may one day be a creature which, if you saw it now, you would be strongly tempted to worship, or else a horror and a corruption such as you now meet, if at all, only in a nightmare. All day long we are, in some degree, helping each other to one or other of these destinations. It is in the light of these overwhelming possibilities, it is with the awe and the circumspection proper to them, that we should conduct all our dealings with one another, all friendships, all loves, all play, all politics. There are no 'ordinary' people. You have never talked to a mere mortal. Nations, cultures, arts, civilisations -- these are mortal, and their life is to ours as the life of a gnat. But it is immortals whome we joke with, work with, marry, snub and exploit -- immortal horrors or everlasting splendours. This does not mean that we are to be perpetually solemn. We must play. But our merriment must be of that kind (and it is, in fact, the merriest kind) which exists between people who have, from the outset, taken each other seriously -- no flippancy, no superiority, no presumption. And our charity must be a real and costly love, with deep feeling for the sins in spite of which we love the sinner -- no mere tolerance or indulgence which parodies love as flippancy parodies merriment."

--C. S. Lewis, From The Weight of Glory

So easy for me to say : "Love Thy Neighbour". How many times have I chosen to love those only who are more interesting, more beautiful, more happy, or those who can love me back. So easy to procrastinate a phone call back to a lonely faraway friend, to hasten a boring conversation, ignore an email, and avoid the funny-shaped sheep of Christ.

But for the help of God, it is impossible to love.

Monday, September 25, 2006

Finding God V: Conversations that Disturb and Entice

(from page 191)

"Moving through our problems toward finding God requires a fresh understanding of community and a courageous willingness to enter it. We must learn how to talk with one another so that the object of our conversation is to disturb one another with how manipulative, defensive, self-serving we are. Our conversations must also entice us to influence others for good, to enjoy our uniqueness, to rest fully in the goodness of God, no matter what happens.

When community is working, tensions may seem unresolvable and pressures overwhelming, but the opportunity to find God will remain if we stay involved. We must not yield to the urge to retreat into the silence of safe superficial chatter. We must keep talking. And our words must matter.

The richest conversations always tell a story. Each of our lives is a dramatic story of how a relational, passionate, thoughtful, purposeful and depraved person handles the experience of life. Woven into our story will always be the tragedy of our using people, our defending ourselves against them, and our worshipping ourselves. The fallen structure within each of us sees to that.

But the indelible stamp of the Savious insures that the story will also include a tale of noble inspiration, usually in an almost unrecognizable subplot, but still undeniably present. Those good passions, whether smothered beneath bad ones that rule us or released to become a driving force, are neither effective or commendable until they draw their energy from a confidence in God's goodness.

Both the storyteller and the listener need to hear the doubting soul struggling to find an identity. They need to look eagerly for the movement of God that frees people to give, to be, and to worship. Typically, conversations that lead us toward a deeper awareness of God first disrupt, then entice.

Most interactions should be pleasant ("Hi , how are you?"), functional ("Would you pick me from the airport?") or important ("As elders, we need to decide how we are going to deal with this disturbing news.") No one is quite so irritating as the junior counsellor who turns normal conversations into therapy sessions. Uninvited probing into motives and weighty expressions of concern spoil pleasant, functional and important conversations.

But true community must include meaningful moments when the quality of our relationships with God, others, and ourselves are discussed. Each of us have friends who know us well and care about us, friends who live honestly enough to wrestle with unanswered questions. With those friends, we need to risk a level of self-disclosure that makes us uncomfortable.
...
Good conversations are often disturbing. They deal with the edge in someone's voice that puts others on guard. They face up to the pain that a friend's snub or a parent's neglect has provoked. Good conversations uncover the terror and rage that often lie hidden beneath a veneer of comfortable relationship. If there aren't times when the very foundations of our relationships are torn away and we continue on only because of Christ, we are not building strong and real relationships."

(Exhibition, Caixa Forum, Barcelona)

Sunday, June 11, 2006

A Connecting Question

Fell asleep on this rainy Sunday afternoon counting the "funny-shaped sheep of God" one has encountered in the past week. Thinking quite a lot these few days about the potential for powerful kindness, and equally powerful cruelty, within the people of God in church. One heals, the other destroys. Crabb thinks that our ability to reach through the bad dynamics of sinful hearts and touch the holy appetites beneath depends on the answer to this question:

"Are we so empowered by the Gospel that we are disposed to continue believing in another's miraculously granted goodness, and to therefore find delight in the other, no matter what degree of ugliness we encounter?"

- From "Connecting", by Larry Crabb

Saturday, April 15, 2006

The Gospel of Judas


The Gospel of Judas premiered one month ahead of The Da Vinci Code on the National Geographic Channel last Sunday. Everyday on the way to work this week, the pre-recorded voice of the Class 95 DJ (quite possibly following a standard trailer script of NGM used around the world) invited viewers to tune in the NG programme on cable "to understand the gospel like it never was understood before" and to discover "how the most hated man in history in fact knew more about the truth than anyone else". At church, fellow JFNers talked hushedly about it. "eh, have you heard?" and at one work luncheon, an articulate fellow member of the profession alluded knowingly to "the suppression of information for political means".

Being a minimum subscriber of Starhub Max Online, and having been brought up in a Hakka household to watch almost no TV, I am a happy survivor of Mediacorp TV, and do not have an SCV subscription for the Treehouse. So I missed both the premiere of the Judas story and the repeat telecast on NGC. However, there were enough second hand witness accounts to give one an idea of what went on during the programme. MOWL, on Thursday evening, gave us cable-less folks a particularly useful account of the program, including the casting of the characters. While Jesus was given the due and respectful glowing aura, Judas was clearly a cut above the rest of the disciples, looking smart and clean shaven beside the rather unkempt and bumbling Peter (poor dear Peter, always an easy target for this sort of thing!). One can imagine how entirely plausible it must have looked on reel for Jesus to pick Judas out from the band of twelve as the only one to whom the "mysteries of the kingdom" would be revealed. One was originally hoping that NG would perhaps have refrained from using these techniques - I have always had much respect for the magazine for being a "BBC" rather than a "CNN" of educational TV, i.e. choosing understatement over sensationalism. But I suppose the imminent Da Vinci blockbuster (expected to be the biggest of ALL TIME) is hard to ignore - NGM may not be able to get Tom Hanks to appear on the show, but it did pay a handsome sum for the text of the Gospel of Judas, and so there are bottomlines to consider, I am sure, and the DVDs need to sell reasonably well.

Now, all in all, I have to admit that I can't say that I was too "fazed" by the Gospel of Judas. Perhaps only a little more so than the Da Vinci Code (which read, so obviously from page 1, like a script prepared for Hollywood, that I almost feel sorry for Dan Brown for having to take so much heat from the church). The question of canonicity of the Bible books has always been a somewhat delicate one for this Bible-believer and perhaps others. When something shows up as a "Gospel", it's only natural to ask, oh dear, did we miss this out from "inerrant, infallible and all sufficient Word of God (not tolerable to a BP-molded mind, even a reformed one)? Or more scary, what else did the Fathers miss out and what did they exclude by mistake?

The "fazing" lasted for all of 20 minutes, thanks largely and ironically to the National Geographic Magazine. The TV special aside (which like I mentioned I haven't watched) there really is a lot of balanced and useful information on the NGM website on the document itself. The actual translation, as well the original Coptic manuscripts are all available for viewing on the NGM website (thanks here to the ever curious minded Mystery C., who first examined the primary materials and forwarded them to me). As one blog pastor points out, this is probably the first time that the average person has such direct access to the study of ancient texts. And any Christians who are minded to watch the TV special should read the translation of the "gospel" text before or after. The contrast to the canoncial Gospels is great indeed. Not to take lightly the job of the Church Fathers and various Councils who had to decide on the weighty issues of canonicity, but perhaps it is really not all that impossible to exclude (with or without impunity), a "Gospel" with a protaganist who purportedly said to Jesus "I know who you are and where you have come from. You are from the immortal realm of Barbelo. And I am not worthy to utter the name of the one who has sent you."

The bigger puzzlement left in my mind from this episode (no pun intended!), like I was telling Mystery C. after we had a good guffaw about Barbelo, was why I didn't feel that terribly "worked up" about it (and for that matter, the whole DVC debate), as I would have as new believer or seeker years ago. I do remember those days of going through tomes of apologetic literature (or whatever one could find for free at the NLB or the church library) trying to figure out, with not a little fear and trembling, whether evolutionary creationism or German higher criticism would deal the death blow to my (newfound) faith in the God of the Bible. I figured it might be due to any or all of these (i) being a little more equipped over the years the "test the faith"; (ii) knowing that pure intellectual persuasion or dissuasion alone does not get one to Critical Point anyway; or (iii) [gulp] just being old and convinced like Solomon that "there is nothing new under the sun".

We were, of course, reminded by Pastor Chia last week during his DVC series sermon that as Christians, we ought always be ready to defend the faith against the current sensationalistic theories, and I gather, to be ready to give a reason for our faith. The power of the media is strong indeed - if seeing is believing, and if facts and information can be presented (manipulated) in a way that catches the [increasingly short] attention [span] of modern folks, there is real work that the church needs to do to bring the authentic gospel to the world.

It is indeed a very wonderful thing to come that stage of one's Christian walk where one no longer feels so easily "blown about by every wind" or affected every Holy Grail movie...but dear Lord, let it not be for the lack of diligence or failure of empathy for the sincere seeker, that this commissioned advocate for You stands down at the surrebuttal.